The BCS proves one
thing.. college football is not the NFL
Another college football season is in the books with Alabama declared the Bowl Championship Series winner and USA Today coaches poll national champion. The Crimson Tide shut out former number one LSU 21-0 to win the BCS title game. But what was the aftermath of that game? More talk about tweaking the BCS, adding teams to form a ‘four team ‘ playoff format, to crown a more legitimate champ. Look, here is the issue. Led by ESPN, or as former Daytonian Dan Patrick calls the ‘mothership’, all the media pundits are trying to make college football like the NFL. It’s not, thankfully. The NFL has always been about championships.
Even before the Super Bowl era, there was the history of NFL championship games, involving the Browns of Paul Brown, Lombardi's Packers and the famous Colts victory over the Giants in the 1958 NFL title game, the first must see TV game in NFL history. In the Super Bowl era, the title game is the goal of all NFL teams. The regular season is a prelude to the playoffs and Super Bowl. Super Bowl Sunday has become a national day of honoring football and its rich tradition in our sporting history. College football is not about crowning a champion. It is about student athletes, ages 18-22, playing football on a college campus, a place of learning for young people. The players are performing for their peers, other students. The biggest games of the season for college teams are against their biggest rivals. The most popular weekends in college football are the weekends when the rivals meet: Ohio State- Michigan, Georgia-Florida, USC-Notre Dame, Oklahoma-Texas. It is these games that define college football, not a BCS championship game. The regular season in college football is the game, on the campuses where students eat, sleep, go to class and earn their degrees. It is tailgating by alumni, throcking to spirit shops and enjoying fall colors on a college campus.
In 1902, the head of the Tournament of Roses parade in Pasadena, California asked the University of Michigan football team to come out to California to play a football game against Stanford on New Year’s Day to help promote his parade. Little did he know that the game, which wouldn’t be played again until 1919, would begin a tradition of playing bowl games on New Year’s Day, six weeks after the end of the regular season. It has never really made sense for teams to stop playing in November and then after Christmas travel to a far away site to practice for another game. It’s almost like a different season. But a parade director wasn’t too concerned about whether it made sense for a football team. He was interested in promoting his parade.
Now the TV moguls want to again alter
tradition. They are trying to make college football a copy of the NFL
playoffs. Why? Well, television money of course. But the rich tradition of
college football is on campuses and at universities across the nation. The
alumni and friends of colleges follow their teams as they compete, learn,
grow and battle their rivals, all the while entertained by the marching band
leading the crowd in the school’s fight song. It’s the games that count. Not
the national championships. College football is not the NFL.
Alright Cleveland Browns fans, I know you are out there.
You may be hiding, but you are there.
However far back you go in
Browns history, chime in now; what should the Browns do to bring back their
fans, some interest, some excitement, maybe some success? How about this:
hire Jim Tressel. If not as head coach, then as a quarterbacks coach on the
staff of new head coach—Mike Holmgren.
The Browns need some serious help. Pat Shurmur
is not the answer. For too long the Browns have played with little passion,
mediocre execution and moderate level talent. They have
passed on superior talent in the draft to take players that have not
panned out or were later traded.
They made a quality trade for Peyton Hillis,
then saw him go in the tank in a season where all indications were he was
ready to lead the Browns to the playoffs. Once again this season, there
appears to be a dispassionate coach leading an underachieving team with
Shurmur in his first year with Cleveland. Holmgren, with Super Bowl
experience, needs to come down from the front office to the sideline.
Here is the Tressel theory, and it is out on a
limb, yes. Jim Tressel is now going to coach in the NFL, or not at all. He
made mistakes with Ohio State that cost him his college coaching career,
which was noteworthy. He is a native of northeast Ohio, and has a history of
coaching quarterbacks, and winning football games. His
history is also in a pro style offense, not the ‘west coast’ offense that
Holmgren and Shurmur run. Tressel won at Ohio State by running the football,
playing solid defense and emphasizing
field position. He also liked quarterbacks who were mobile and could
throw the ball deep.
Tressel has some connections in the NFL, and
visited the Browns camp last summer. Mike Holmgren should take the head
coaching job, hire Tressel to work under him, and after three seasons, give
Tressel the job.
The former Buckeye boss has the skills to
handle pro players. He has spent his whole life coaching football and knows
talent. He has great in-game skill in reading situations, play calling and
use of time outs, replay review and personnel.
This is simply the right time to make this
move, for the Browns and for Tressel. There are four good reasons to do it:
Chris Palmer, Butch Davis, Romeo Crennel and Eric Mangini. Do you need a
fifth? Oh, Pat Shurmur. Besides, what other options do the Browns have now?
And what about this: After they move Holmgren to the sidelines and hire
Tressel—trade a draft pick this year to the Raiders for ex-Buckeye Terrell
Pryor. Would that stand the town on it’s head? Crazier things have happened.
Look at Tim Tebow in Denver. Case closed.